Atlantic Council Warns AI Could Evade Biological Attribution

Artificial intelligence can already design novel biological threats and could eventually create agents that evade existing attribution methods, according to a new Atlantic Council report. The report calls for US attribution capabilities to keep pace, including stronger coordination before a biological event occurs.
- AI can already design novel biological threats, according to the Atlantic Council.
- Some future agents could evade existing attribution methods.
- US biological attribution responsibilities are distributed across multiple agencies.
- The report calls for evidence, intelligence, and information-sharing procedures before an event occurs.
Why biological attribution matters
Attribution means determining where a biological threat came from and who was responsible. The Atlantic Council says the United States must be able to make that determination to hold attackers accountable, but also to respond appropriately when an event is accidental or natural.
Establishing an accidental origin could help the government put preventative measures in place and avoid a repeat. Evidence of a natural event could help officials understand which natural vectors might produce a catastrophic biological event. The report says public health officials and investigators must work simultaneously, with the cause of an event influencing law enforcement and intelligence responses in the days, weeks, and months that follow.
If investigators find evidence of an intentional attack, the findings could prompt discussions across the federal government and ultimately reach the White House, where officials would consider responsibility and possible measures to punish or deter perpetrators.
Lessons from the anthrax investigation
The report points to the anthrax attacks that followed 9/11 as an example of the scale and difficulty of biological attribution. The investigation involved thousands of interviews, tens of thousands of digital documents and emails, and dozens of laboratories. Questions about its findings persist today.
Biological attribution can be imprecise because it often combines scientific, intelligence, and investigative evidence. The Atlantic Council warns that officials could accuse a suspect before the available evidence supports the conclusion, creating diplomatic and security risks.
Capabilities have improved since the 2001 attacks, but the report says the United States is still not fully prepared to determine responsibility for the next biological attack.
A fragmented system facing an AI challenge
Responsibility for attribution is distributed across several parts of the US government. The FBI leads federal criminal investigations, while the Department of Homeland Security owns and manages the laboratory used by the FBI for attributional work. Under the 2022 National Biodefense Strategy and Implementation Plan, the Secretary of Health and Human Services co-leads attribution. The intelligence community separately gathers information, including in some cases within hostile territory.
The Atlantic Council says procedures exist at the highest levels of government, but the current approach has not comprehensively unified these elements or ensured that information reaches decision-makers in a timely way. It calls for procedures, protocols, and information-sharing mechanisms to be established before an event occurs.
Those arrangements must cover evidence collection, evaluation of competing explanations, and communication of findings. Officials also need to understand the evidentiary and intelligence thresholds for judging responsibility.
What the report means for biodefense
The report presents AI as both a source of risk and a potential tool for improving attribution. Its warning is that biological attribution must advance alongside AI's ability to design threats, including threats that could escape existing methods of identification.
The report was produced by the Bipartisan Commission on Biodefense at the Atlantic Council, a privately funded entity established in 2014 to assess US biodefense efforts and issue recommendations. Its findings place faster coordination and clearer decision-making at the center of preparations for future biological events.
Atlantic Council (AI): Seeking the source: Biological attribution from anthrax to AI


